Page 146 - GSTL_16th July 2020_Vol. 38_Part 3
P. 146

384                           GST LAW TIMES                      [ Vol. 38
                                                 common land  and common entrance  and therefore, in generic
                                                 terms, a housing project can be defined as a project having common
                                                 facilities, common entrance, common area, common land etc.  The
                                                 benefit of the said notification would be available to the applicant
                                                 subject to the condition that he builds a housing project using 50%
                                                 or more of the FAR/FSI for dwelling units with carpet area upto 60
                                                 square metres.
                                            (b)  The applicant has also submitted that he is developing a township,
                                                 which is a continuous process and not limited to one or two phases
                                                 of development; that entire area of a township cannot be considered
                                                 for arriving at 50% or more FSI as required under the Notification
                                                 dated 30-3-2017,; that a project is complete project in itself which is
                                                 independent  of other projects (within township) which are either
                                                 completed before, during or after completion of Part B of Sector 4;
                                                 that as township is a continuous development process, it is not hav-
                                                 ing any fixed total area under development and hence it could not
                                                 have a fixed FSI as required under the notification dated 30-3-2017;
                                                 that a township is different from  a  standalone housing project
                                                 which is undertaken for a particular class of people and shall com-
                                                 prise of houses for all sections of the society; that a township is an
                                                 integration of various projects for different types of people of socie-
                                                 ty i.e. higher, middle and weaker class of people; thus, Part-B is in-
                                                 dependent project for affordable housing  and total FSI of  Part-B
                                                 should be considered as denominator to arrive at 50% as required
                                                 under notification dated 30-3-2017. In this regard, it is to mention
                                                 that the representatives of the applicant have submitted during the
                                                 course of personal hearing that they have received common permis-
                                                 sion for entire land housing Part-A and Part-B of Sector-4 and that
                                                 the entire Sector-4  (of Amba township) is having a common en-
                                                 trance, common facilities, common area common land etc. and it in-
                                                 cludes Part-A (Phase-I and II) and Part-B. The applicant has submit-
                                                 ted a photocopy of the said permission received by them which con-
                                                 tains the ‘Layout plan showing proposed  residential building in
                                                 Block No. 444/260.P. (Sub Plot No. R1) at Adalaj Taluka and Dis-
                                                 trict-Gandhinagar issued by the Junior Town Planner, Gandhinagar
                                                 Urban Development Authority on 16-9-2016. The said plan shows
                                                 the layout of all the proposed buildings of Part-A and Part-B as well
                                                 as the internal roads, common areas etc. Further, Table-A and Ta-
                                                 ble-B therein contains exclusive details such as the number of units
                                                 to be constructed in each building, their built-up area, total built-up
                                                 area etc. Therefore, we  are of the opinion that when a common
                                                 permission has been obtained from the concerned authorities for the
                                                 entire township containing of Part-A and Part-B which is also hav-
                                                 ing a common entrance, common facilities, common land etc., then
                                                 the entire township has to be considered as a single housing project.
                                                 Thus, for a housing project to be considered a standalone housing
                                                 project, the basic condition would be to have a common entrance,
                                                 common facilities, common area, common land, etc. In the instant
                                                 case, Part-B of Sector-4 (of Amba Township) would qualify to be a
                                                           GST LAW TIMES      16th July 2020      146
   141   142   143   144   145   146   147   148   149   150   151